The Enduring Saga: Wampanoag History and the Plymouth Colony Exhibit
The story of Plymouth Colony and the Wampanoag people is often distilled into a romanticized narrative, particularly around the American holiday of Thanksgiving. However, a deeper, more nuanced understanding reveals a complex, often tragic, and profoundly intertwined history of two distinct cultures meeting, clashing, and ultimately shaping the trajectory of North America. Modern historical exhibits, notably those at Plimoth Patuxet Museums (formerly Plimoth Plantation), endeavor to present this multifaceted history with greater accuracy, empathy, and a crucial emphasis on Indigenous perspectives.
Part 1: Wampanoag History – A Legacy of Resilience and Sovereignty
For over 12,000 years, the Wampanoag people, whose name translates to "People of the First Light," have inhabited the southeastern coast of Massachusetts and eastern Rhode Island, including Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket. Their sophisticated society thrived long before European contact, built upon a deep understanding of their ancestral lands, known as Patuxet.
Pre-Contact Society: The Wampanoag lived in permanent villages during spring and summer, cultivating crops like corn, beans, and squash (the "Three Sisters" agriculture), which provided a sustainable food source. They also engaged in extensive hunting, fishing, and gathering, moving seasonally to exploit different resources. Their homes, called wetus or nushwetu (wigwams), were dome-shaped structures made of saplings and bark or woven mats, designed for comfort and mobility.
Their social and political structure was organized into a confederation of tribes, each led by a sachem (leader) or sachemqua (female leader). Decisions were made through consensus, with sachems acting as respected arbitrators and representatives. Spiritual beliefs were central, revolving around a reverence for the natural world and a complex cosmology involving various spiritual beings and a Great Spirit. Oral traditions, storytelling, and ceremonial practices passed down knowledge and cultural values through generations. Trade networks extended far beyond their immediate territory, connecting them with other Indigenous nations across the Northeast.
Early European Contact and Catastrophe: While the Pilgrims’ arrival in 1620 is often cited as the first major European encounter, Wampanoag people had interacted with European fishermen and traders for over a century prior. These early encounters, while sometimes involving trade, also brought violence, kidnapping, and, most devastatingly, unseen pathogens.
Between 1616 and 1619, a series of epidemics (likely leptospirosis, but possibly smallpox or other European diseases) ravaged the Wampanoag and neighboring Indigenous populations. This "Great Dying" wiped out an estimated 75-90% of the Wampanoag population, leaving entire villages desolate, including Patuxet, the very village upon which the Pilgrims would later establish Plymouth. This demographic catastrophe profoundly weakened the Wampanoag confederation, leaving them vulnerable and altering the balance of power in the region.
The Arrival of the Mayflower and the Treaty of 1621: When the Mayflower arrived in November 1620, the Wampanoag sachem Massasoit Ousamequin, leader of the Pokanoket Wampanoag, faced a difficult strategic choice. His people were decimated by disease, and they were under threat from the powerful Narragansett to the west. Recognizing the potential for an alliance, Massasoit initiated contact with the struggling English settlers.
Tisquantum (Squanto), a Patuxet Wampanoag who had been kidnapped by an English explorer, taken to Europe, and later returned, played a pivotal role. His ability to speak English and his knowledge of both cultures made him an invaluable interpreter and mediator. He taught the Pilgrims how to cultivate native crops, fish, and identify edible wild plants – knowledge essential for their survival.
In March 1621, Massasoit and Governor John Carver of Plymouth Colony signed a treaty of mutual defense and peace. This treaty, based on a pragmatic alliance rather than simple friendship, stipulated that neither side would harm the other, that they would aid each other in defensive wars, and that they would report any wrongdoing. The famous "First Thanksgiving" of autumn 1621 was not a singular event of inter-cultural harmony but a harvest celebration and a political affirmation of this fragile alliance, with Massasoit and 90 Wampanoag men joining the 50 surviving Pilgrims for three days of feasting and diplomacy.
Erosion of Peace and King Philip’s War: Over the subsequent decades, the relationship deteriorated. As the English population grew, so did their demand for land, often acquired through deceptive means or outright encroachment. Cultural differences, particularly regarding land ownership (the Wampanoag viewed land as communal, for use, not for exclusive possession), and English legal imposition, created increasing friction.
Upon Massasoit’s death in 1661, his son Wamsutta (Alexander) briefly succeeded him, followed by Metacom (Philip). Metacom, witnessing the relentless expansion and the erosion of Wampanoag sovereignty, foresaw the complete subjugation of his people. He attempted to forge a pan-Indigenous alliance to resist the English.
In 1675, these simmering tensions erupted into King Philip’s War (also known as Metacom’s War), one of the bloodiest conflicts in American colonial history. The war devastated both English and Indigenous communities, but its impact on the Wampanoag and other New England tribes was catastrophic. Thousands of Indigenous people were killed, enslaved, or displaced. Metacom was eventually hunted down and killed in August 1676, effectively ending organized Indigenous resistance in southern New England and marking the end of Indigenous sovereignty in the region. While many Wampanoag were scattered, enslaved, or forced into subservience, pockets of resilience endured, ensuring the survival of their culture and identity to the present day.
Part 2: Plymouth Colony – Aspirations and Hardships
The English settlers who established Plymouth Colony were a diverse group, primarily composed of Separatists (known as Pilgrims), who sought religious freedom from the Church of England, and "Strangers," who were primarily economic migrants.
Motivations and the Voyage: The Separatists had initially fled to Leiden, Holland, but feared their children were losing their English identity and sought a place where they could practice their faith freely and establish a "godly commonwealth." They secured a patent from the Virginia Company and, along with the Strangers, embarked on the Mayflower in September 1620.
Founding and Early Struggles: Blown off course, they landed far north of their intended destination, at Cape Cod, and eventually settled at Patuxet. Before disembarking, 41 adult male passengers signed the Mayflower Compact, a foundational document of self-governance, establishing a "civil body politic" and agreeing to abide by its laws.
The first winter was brutal. Malnutrition, disease (scurvy, pneumonia), and the harsh New England climate decimated their ranks; nearly half of the 102 passengers died. Their survival was largely due to the unexpected assistance of the Wampanoag people, particularly Tisquantum, who shared vital knowledge of the land and its resources.
Development of the Colony: Plymouth gradually grew, though it remained smaller and less influential than the later Massachusetts Bay Colony. Its economy initially relied on fur trading, fishing, and timber, supplemented by subsistence farming. Governance evolved from the Mayflower Compact to a representative assembly. Over time, Plymouth exerted its influence over surrounding Indigenous communities, often through missionary efforts and the establishment of "praying towns." The colony maintained its independence until 1691 when it was absorbed into the larger Massachusetts Bay Colony.
Part 3: Interpreting History – The Plymouth Colony Exhibit
Modern historical exhibits, particularly at institutions like Plimoth Patuxet Museums in Plymouth, Massachusetts, have undergone a significant evolution in how they present the story of the Wampanoag and Plymouth Colony. Moving beyond a singular, Eurocentric narrative, these exhibits strive for a dual, balanced, and culturally sensitive interpretation.
Evolution of Interpretation: For much of the 20th century, museums often presented a romanticized view of the Pilgrims as pioneers of religious freedom, with the Wampanoag relegated to a supporting role or largely ignored. However, the rise of Indigenous rights movements, new archaeological discoveries, and a commitment to more inclusive historical scholarship have driven a profound shift. Today’s exhibits aim to challenge myths, acknowledge the complexities and tragedies, and, most importantly, give voice to the Indigenous perspective.
Plimoth Patuxet Museums: A Dual Narrative: Plimoth Patuxet Museums stands as a premier example of this new approach. It comprises several key components designed to immerse visitors in both the Wampanoag and English worlds of the 17th century:
-
Wampanoag Homesite: This living history exhibit is dedicated to presenting the Wampanoag experience from a Wampanoag perspective. Crucially, it is staffed by contemporary Wampanoag and other Native American interpreters. These interpreters do not portray historical figures but represent themselves, sharing their culture, history, and traditions directly with visitors. They speak the Wôpanâak language (a language revitalized by the Wôpanâak Language Reclamation Project), demonstrate traditional crafts like weaving, cooking, and building wetus, and explain Wampanoag worldviews, seasonal cycles, and social structures. The Homesite focuses on the period before and during early contact, emphasizing the richness and resilience of Wampanoag culture rather than solely their interactions with Europeans. This approach empowers Indigenous voices and challenges visitors to see history through a different lens.
-
17th-Century English Village: This immersive exhibit recreates the Plymouth Colony of 1627. Costumed interpreters, speaking in first-person as historical residents of Plymouth, engage visitors in conversations about their daily lives, beliefs, struggles, and aspirations. Visitors can explore historically accurate houses, see livestock, observe traditional farming practices, and witness colonial crafts. The interpreters discuss their reasons for coming to America, their religious convictions, their hardships, and their evolving relationship with the Wampanoag, often reflecting the biases and understandings of the period.
-
Mayflower II: A full-scale reproduction of the original Mayflower, this ship provides insight into the perilous voyage across the Atlantic. Interpreters discuss the conditions aboard, the challenges of seafaring in the 17th century, and the motivations of the passengers.
-
Henry Hornblower II Visitor Center and Craft Center: These areas house more traditional museum exhibits with artifacts, maps, and multimedia presentations that provide broader historical context for both cultures. They also feature contemporary Wampanoag art, history, and cultural programs, connecting the past to the present and underscoring the ongoing vitality of Wampanoag communities.
Challenges and Significance: Presenting this dual narrative is not without its challenges. Museums must continuously strive for authenticity, avoid tokenism, and ensure that the Indigenous voice is not just present but central and empowered. The interpretive narratives must be dynamic, reflecting new scholarship and ongoing dialogue with Indigenous communities.
The significance of these exhibits lies in their ability to foster a more complete and empathetic understanding of American history. By presenting the Wampanoag experience alongside that of the Plymouth colonists, they reveal a story not of simple triumph or easy friendship, but of complex coexistence, profound cultural clashes, and enduring resilience. They remind us that history is a contested terrain, continuously reinterpreted, and that understanding the perspectives of all involved is crucial for a meaningful engagement with the past and for building a more just future. The Wampanoag people, far from being a historical footnote, continue to thrive, asserting their sovereignty and sharing their history, ensuring that the "People of the First Light" remain a vital part of the American story.
